I had always assumed that the strangeness I carried—my deep love of silence, my need for solitude, my particular peculiarities—be- longed either to my poetic temperament or to some unhealed wound. When I encountered Thirty Two Short Films About Glenn Gould as an impressionable young man, I somehow felt less alone. François Girard’s film resists conventional biography. It unfolds as a series of meditations, glimpses of a life arranged like musical variations.
In one fragment, we watch Gould’s hands disappear into a basin of warm water, the camera lingering on this private ritual that preceded each public performance. The water steams slightly. His fingers flex and curl with the deliberate attention of a surgeon preparing for operation. As someone who, decades into the literary game, has still not made peace with public speaking, I recognize now the meaning of such self-soothing routines. For a nervous system so finely tuned, every aspect of such a deliberate ritual, from the temperature of the water to the depth of breathing, is refuge.
Another scene: Gould at his piano in the recording studio, humming along as he plays. The soundtrack becomes a duet between fingers and voice; Bach’s mathematics lends structure. His humming is unselfconscious, compulsive. A kind of vocal stimming that, lat- er, would be recognized as common among autistic individuals. But here it becomes something else: a second melody winding through the Goldberg Variations, like a prayer spoken just under breath.
Perhaps most haunting is the moment he renounces concert performance. We see Gould backstage, overwhelmed not merely by stage fright, but by sensory assault: the rustling of programs, the intense gaze of the audience, the glare of stage lights. His remark that public performance was “a force of evil” no longer reads as posturing. It reads as a reckoning for a mind that craved music, within a body that could not endure the conditions required to share it.
Here’s an echo, a poem that I wrote about the dreadful experience of reading in public:
I was still in college when, upon the recommendation of a com- plicated friend, I went alone to watch the Gould film. My friend with wicked relish told me to expect to meet myself on the silver screen. It was not exactly a compliment. He knew me well enough to tease me the way a sibling might. And sure enough, up there in the darkened, nearly empty cinema room, what struck my friend (and the world) as eccentric in Gould seemed strangely intimate, despite the lack of any musical talent on my part.
In Gould’s rituals and refusals, I began to discern a sensibility I had encountered elsewhere, in other artists and thinkers. Say, Dickinson’s austere order and white garments, or Wittgenstein’s retreat from the world into a cabin of logic and silence. In my own rhythms, which lean toward stillness and structure. The film, like the Goldberg Variations themselves, invites us into a different form of understanding that reveals itself in pattern.
More recently, this realization resurfaced as I watched Love on the Spectrum, a sweetly innocent series following autistic adults as they navigate intimacy. Their careful speech, their unwavering enthusiasms, their longing for clarity felt uncannily familiar. It was as though they were missing a protective skin and inhabited a vulnerable state of being. Once again, I watched not from the outside, but from within a quiet kinship.
And so a question stirred, one I had never fully articulated. What if what I had long believed to be a spiritual apartness was also neurological proximity? What if the boundaries we draw between the mystical, the artistic, and the autistic blur more than we know? Of course, I do not claim to diagnose. The dead deserve their mysteries. But I do wish to reflect on the possibility that many of those canonized as seers, visionaries, or artists lived with traits we now associate with autism. To consider this does not reduce their oddity; it takes it seriously.
Until recently, there were few names for such minds. These traits were often moralized, spiritualized, or misunderstood: the monk in his cell, the painter obsessively returning to one shade of blue, the philosopher lost in a system only he could trace. Their lives were folded into stories of sainthood or madness. Yet these figures often show patterns that echo what science now plainly describes: a sensitivity to noise, an intense focus, a resistance to ordinary social cues, a longing for order in a chaotic world.
Gould was never formally diagnosed. Speculation that he may have been on the autism spectrum emerged after his death in 1982. Still, his habits have been studied closely. His sensitivity to touch, for exam- ple, or his preference for the controlled environment of a studio to the unpredictability of audiences. He dressed in layers against the slightest chill. He was wary of interruption. None of this was affectation. These were terms of survival.
Girard’s film reveals this with quiet tenderness. In one segment, Gould records the same passage of Bach repeatedly, each take minutely different. What might seem obsessive begins to resemble a kind of spiritual practice. Not perfectionism, but devotion. Each return a gesture of reverence. Each variation a deepening.
Here, too, what appears eccentric reveals itself as engineering: the careful construction of conditions under which a particular kind of mind can do its work.
Girard’s film reveals something else about Gould, something that complicates the image of the withdrawn artist. Here was a man capable of theatrical phone conversations that stretched for hours, who could mimic voices and accents with delightful precision, who engaged deeply with literature and philosophy. The same person who fled concert halls could be charming, witty, given to elaborate intellectual play-acting. In one segment, we glimpse him constructing complex personas for his liner notes, inventing fictional critics to debate his interpretations.
Again, as a social hermit myself, I recognized this multiplicity as a product of the rich inner life that solitude and stillness make pos- sible. Perhaps this is why I felt such affinity with this intimate stranger, beyond our shared September 25th birth date. I recognized the seeming contradiction: the need for retreat coupled with an irrepressible intellectual sociability, the longing for silence that coexists with an interior world buzzing with conversation, argument, and wit. By association, somehow I think of a line by Kafka, where he writes that “Social in- tercourse seduces us into self-contemplation.” Of course, we must each negotiate that fine balance for ourselves and admittedly, the social intercourse/self-contemplation ratio varies widely for different types.
Again, compulsively, I revisit certain clues in artists I admire. Dickinson, composing in her room, protected by ceremony. Her letters speak of sound and light as overwhelming. Visitors unsettled her; routine steadied her. That fly, in the famous poem, may not have been symbol but fact. The buzz so sharp it drowned everything else—even death.
Van Gogh’s letters and paintings tremble with similar sensitivity. He saw the world charged, vibrating. Recent research into synesthesia and autism suggests that some minds do experience such crossings of the senses, not metaphorically, but literally.
In mystical literature, the descriptions align once more. Teresa of Ávila wrote of her visions as too vivid to bear. Her ecstasies were not abstractions but physical, nearly painful. Presence, for her, came as pressure. Repetition, in contemplative traditions—mantra, rosary, chant—serves as anchor. These are ways to preserve coherence under conditions of excess.
And still the question: who is allowed to live that way, and under what conditions? Newton’s strangeness was forgiven for the sake of his discoveries. Beethoven’s withdrawal was rendered heroic by his music. Others—especially women, or those outside sanctioned categories—were not so generously interpreted. Their difference was read as deficiency.
Girard’s film holds this tension without trying to resolve it. One scene lingers on Gould at a dinner party. Conversation buzzes around him. He retreats inward, not rudely but helplessly. The camera does not judge. It simply watches a man exiled by his own nervous system.
Girard lingers, too, on Gould’s infamous piano stool: a collapsing relic held together with wire, screws, and stubborn loyalty. He carried this personal relic from studio to studio, a security blanket that looked absurd to others but was essential to him. The camera catches it in several frames: battered, jury-rigged, somehow still functional. It becomes a perfect emblem of neurodivergent existence—something that appears broken from the outside but serves its purpose beautifully for the one who needs it. The stool was cut down to a precise height, adjusted to his exact specifications. Like his rituals with warm water, like his layers of clothing, like his retreat from audiences, it was part of the elaborate scaffolding he built to make music possible.
ontemporary neuroscience has begun to consider such minds from a different angle. Some studies link autistic cognition with a propensity for altered states. What scientists call “transient hypofrontality”—the quieting of the prefrontal cortex—resembles the focused absorption described in meditative or creative flow. For some, this state is rare. For others, it may be native.
Another trait often mentioned is “weak central coherence”: the tendency to focus on detail rather than broad picture. Yet this trait has yielded insight of the highest order. Newton, Darwin, Einstein— these were not men in haste. They moved slowly, faithfully, noticing what others skipped. This is not to deny suffering. Neurodivergence is often isolating, difficult to navigate. But neither should we ignore the profound contributions it has enabled. From sacred music to architectural wonder, from mystical texts to poetic form, some of humanity’s finest expressions emerged from minds that moved against the current.
When I visit a monastery, I feel something settle. The hush, the rhythm, the blessed absence of noise, these create the conditions for attention. They make room for the sacred. Similarly, when I read the likes of Dickinson or Wittgenstein, I do not feel as though I am studying them. I feel accompanied. Their worlds, while distinct, are somehow adjacent to mine.
So I return to Girard’s film with a fuller heart. Thirty-two years later, these thirty-two segments offered a kind of listening. Each short film stands as a variation in the deeper sense—a theme turned gently, again and again, until something ineffable appears. In one of the final sequences, we find Gould alone in his studio. The music ends. The self-imposed silence and solitude he sought were necessary conditions for a certain kind of hearing.