An Improbable Quest:

On Birdman of Alcatraz

By

Marilynne Robinson

   I endured a childhood of reasonable calm and comfort, modest adequacy at worst. I did well enough in school. Cats and dogs came and went. The ritual events of my passage through adolescence were duly observed. I learned from those years that an unexceptional life can feel imprisoning. This idea is a powerful cliche in our national culture, one I encountered early. The idea is that to be the product of an ordinary life in a small town dooms one particularly in the matter of developing any individuality worth speaking of, not to mention a mind, properly so called.

No matter. I learned that there were things I was good at. I was clever with my hands. Actually my hands were clever and I watched with some amazement when a line in a drawing went just where it should, more gracefully than I had hoped or anticipated. Sometimes words in my head configured themselves into something I could call a poem. I had no imagination of a future, a fact which made these experiences pure, specimens of the human impulse to contrive, to fabricate, or so it has seemed to me. There was a time when my hands seemed to me as if they had an autonomous life, to grow restless if they were not attempting something intricate. That passed years ago, but I remember the absorption involved, which was a kind of suspenseful joy, a deep physiological reward more exquisite than any I have enjoyed since then. I feel that I know how, in the long primal past, a pot became a jug became a vase. Someone’s hands felt the suave shape that had not existed until that moment. I know it might seem preposterous in me to compare my life to the life of Robert Stroud, a sad, hard man truly entrapped in his psychosis, with nothing more to engage his humanity than a fallen sparrow. But those beautiful hands are not so much purposeful as compelled by an improbable sufficiency to an arbitrary work.

7

   The Birdman of Alcatraz is about a man’s humanization, and also about penal rehabilitation, which is not at all the same thing. “Humanization” is a permissible term here because the central character, Robert Stroud, is seen as settling into himself, finding his own skill and intelligence, rather than accommodating himself to the strategies and coercions of the system that is meant to make him socially viable. It might seem that there would be a point of meeting between the transformation that comes about through his realization of his own very particular abilities, and the intentions of the institutions bent on reforming him. But he dies an old man and still a prisoner. The warden controls the definition of the word “rehabilitation,” which Stroud will never satisfy despite the oddly beautiful thing he has made of his life.

Robert Stroud was a real person, still living at the time the film was made, who had been held in solitary confinement for decades, in Leavenworth, then Alcatraz. The actor Burt Lancaster became aware of him, was appalled by his situation and chose to make a film to draw attention to it, taking the part of Stroud. The film follows the life fairly closely, though it makes no mention of his early life. Stroud ran away from his abusive father at 13 and ended up in Alaska. At seventeen he shot and killed a man for beating and failing to pay a prostitute. He apparently felt that he was justified in this, because he went to the police and turned himself in. This was the beginning of his history with law enforcement.

Lancaster captures a kind of baffled, furious rage which leads to the murder of a prison guard. Stroud is sentenced to hang, but, improbably enough, his mother succeeded in securing a meeting with the wife of President Wilson, who commuted his sentence. The warden, played by Karl Malden, was furious, and he avenged himself. He took the language of the commutation to mean that Stroud was to remain in solitary confinement until he was executed, which, of course, he never would be.

Apparently, Lancaster’s portrayal of Stroud as a mild-mannered and sympathetic character was somewhat misleading, though highly effective. Former inmates who spent time with the actual Stroud in prison described him as “a vicious killer,” a “jerk,” and decidedly “not a sweetheart.” After years in solitary confinement, he did help to end a violent prison rebellion, which led to his being transferred to another prison. By no means a one-dimensional figure, Stroud was for director John Frankenheimer a foundation for developing a character whose inner life, though somewhat obscure to us, was clearly more impressive. The New Yorker film critic Pauline Kael complained in her review of the film that she couldn’t quite believe in the character’s transformation, in the course of his long ordeal, from a man full of rage to the decent fellow portrayed by Lancaster.

The Lancaster character seems to accept the sentence passed upon him—life in solitary—with equanimity, and this seems to us fully plausible. At first, in fact, Stroud redoubles this punishment, on himself, refusing the slightest mitigation. The warden and the prison are the abusive father who strip him of any place in life. His pride is expressed in his acceptance and endurance of this terrible pain.

Then one day, walking around the yard during a rain storm, he notices a hatchling sparrow whose nest has been brought down by the rain. Like the meeting of his mother with the President’s wife, this really happened. The movie sometimes struggles with the gross improbabilities of fact, which can seem very contrived.

Stroud brings the wretched little creature into his cell, and he begins to make a project of keeping it alive. This is the point at which the film becomes itself. The camera will hardly look away from Stroud’s hands, which have a kind of intrinsic humanity by virtue of their adequacy to this work of gentleness. Their sculptural beauty is dwelt upon. And Stroud is a sort of Robinson Crusoe, humanizing an experiential desert by means of sheer ingenuity. The history of the species is as implicit in the hand as in the brain, and a sociopath with a cigarette hanging off his lip can feel its cunning as a marvelous aspect of himself, a singular privilege.

6

   Stroud begins to interact with people as his sparrow requires him to, so that the strictures of his solitude begin to relax. He acquires two parakeets, and in good time they have multiplied and filled his cell. The film evokes Stroud’s fascination with its long attention to an egg, then to the scrawny thing hatching out of it. He publishes articles and becomes, pseudonymously, AN ORNITHOLOGIST, a renowned expert on bird diseases. This is, we remember, a man with a third-grade education. Soon he is abruptly transferred to the new, hygienic prison called Alcatraz—where his nemesis is the warden—, and where pets are forbidden and silence is enforced, and which in time explodes in a riot that is suppressed with great violence. And finally he is a polite and philosophic old man being taken under guard to a prison hospital. In his years at Alcatraz he wrote a book on the history of American penology that seems to have been effectively suppressed. Viewing the film, it is impossible not to think of him—no matter the company or circumstance—as a man with extraordinarily gentle and dexterous hands tending his birds and absorbed completely in an improbable quest for knowledge.

I take the film to be a tale of self-sufficiency discovered in brilliance and capability that is intrinsically human and sustaining, a sufficient claim to dignity in every circumstance.