Most Of What Follows

By

Melora Wolff

FADE IN

I was eight years old when Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid was released. I saw it with my mother in the Sutton theater in New York City in 1969. We went back often to see Sundance and Butch plot and ride, rob and escape, shoot and leap. I was heartsick, smitten with both of these guys, the two outlaws The Kid and Butch and, necessarily, with the two men who made them live on screen, Robert Redford and Paul Newman. And the inscrutable woman of history who loved them both too? I felt I knew her. What became of the actress Katharine Ross, goddess of the era with her radiant smile and ghostly eyes, cast in the role of Etta Place? Even now, Etta moves me. As a child, I believed I was Etta. Or, that Etta was in my family, in my blood. “Not that it matters,” screenwriter William Goldman began his first original screenplay, “but most of what follows is true.” Did Etta matter? She’s barely there. The film’s truth, I believed, was always with Etta.

ETTA WISHES

I walk across the twilit field to my empty house. Each of my days ends in precisely this way: I lock the schoolhouse door after the children have headed home. I move the short distance through the field accompanied by the sound of crickets. I arrive at my small cabin, which is—all things considered—a comfy spot for a woman who understands her life is already, in most respects, unremarkable. “I’m twenty-six, and I’m single, and a schoolteacher and that’s the bottom of the pit.” I admit, that line stings. Even Goldman didn’t like it. And some people still say I wasn’t even a schoolteacher, but a prostitute, and to hell with them. I strike a match to illuminate my day’s lonely end. I unbutton my stiff ruffled blouse. I turn to see the man in the shadows, his gun pointed at me. For him, I will lower my skirt, take down my hair, shake my head for full effect, unbutton myself. “The only excitement I’ve known is here with me now,” I’m scripted to say. But no, Goldman gave me that line to speak later in his film, after Sundance asks me to travel with him and Butch to Bolivia, because I’ll be good cover for them, a woman, when they’re on the run from the posse.

11
Yes, it’s true, these men are my life’s motion. Our triangle suits us, mostly. This cabin scene, early in the film, enters an eight-year old’s breathless body as she watches, and wakes her first desires. She wants to be me. Believes she’s me. She calls herself “Etta.” She wants to be a grown-up woman who loves two men at once, impossibly, and is loved by both, fantastically. One of those two men I love has his gun belt unbuckled. Sundance’s commands are gestures, tilts of the head, controlled by Robert Redford as The Kid. “Do you know what I wish? That once you’d get here on time,” I manage to say before we embrace. Obviously, this situation will end badly for Sundance, Butch, and me, with threat and love so confused. All three of us are long dead. I know this, of course, I’m not stupid, I speak two languages, I can see the future…and so can that small girl in the theater who has seen this movie many times with her mother. They have both entered and claimed the story. The girl is only eight years old and her mother, only thirty-nine. They’re impressionable, and romantics. Both of them are eager for “the only excitement I’ve known” to begin and end at the movies.

ETTA WONDERS

At dawn, the second man I love, Butch, floats by my window, on a new invention of our era, a bicycle. “Meet the future!” he tells me, because at this point the future is still possible for the three of us. Goldman has plans for this bicycle, which will—like our remaining days—cease to matter. He’ll have Butch, disgusted, throw it later into the mud of a stream. “The future is all yours, ya lousy bicycles,” Butch is scripted to say, an outlaw fleeing to South America. He already knows he’s finished. The bicycle’s wheel will spin slowly as the water’s silver currents fade to sepia. But today, in our cinematic present, the morning is vibrant DeLuxe colors. As Butch and I move forward on our new bicycle, we’re barely visible through a bedroom’s lace curtain lifted by a breeze. Who is watching us? Only the motion picture’s camera, the cinematographer Conrad Hall, the director George Roy Hill, decades of movie fans, and that small girl again, beside her mother in the theater’s dark. I’m on the bike’s handlebars. I swish my white scalloped robe from side to side, with Butch’s arms around me. We exist as image-flashes, memories lit beyond tree branches, beyond the slats of a wooden fence, beneath a high loft window that frames our small bodies in a rectangle of sunlight, like a perfect photo hanging on a wall. Five apples on a branch come into focus. I grab one still wet with dew, bite into it and offer a bite to Butch too, as we ride. This is a prelapsarian morning. Our laughter is genuine, and his antics balanced atop the bike are genuine too—Paul Newman really performed these bicycle stunts I love—but we keep our privacy, because Burt Bacharach and Hal David’s “Raindrops Keep Fallin’ On My Head” plays over our intimacies, the way William Goldman wanted. He imagined even the music for his film, a song poignant, pretty, not too loud—song as an emotional comment not a literal one, and this song becomes an immediate classic, the sound of morning and joy, senseless, dizzy, perfect. Goldman loved words, but he understood music too. It’s still early in his film, and I find it impossible not to think about the choices I’ve made, the timing of the past always determining the future, the ways that a man made of silence and motion is as necessary to me as a man who makes me laugh. As the scene ends, Goldman has me speak out loud what worries me the most, “Butch, do you ever wonder if I’d met you first if we’d been the ones to get involved?” And Goldman answers her, or Butch does, “We are involved, Etta, don’t you know that? I mean you are riding on my bicycle—” yes, there’s a second story inside the first, we both close our eyes, hold each other, “that’s the same as being married.” When the movie ends and the men are gone, suspended onscreen in their freeze-framed deaths as the barrage of army bullets resounds, the lights in the theater come up, and the girl’s mother reaches for her daughter’s hand but drops her purse, which slips behind the seats. This mother becomes frantic. She trembles. “Mom!” the eight-year-old shouts, trying to distract her mother from the mood this movie always stirs in them. Outside the Sutton on the city pavement in the rain, the mother tries to hail a taxicab to get them both back home. She never answers the daughter’s question, and it’s always the same question, every time. “Mom, who do you think Etta loves more, Sundance or Butch?”

NOT THAT IT MATTERS

I follow the color of light on film. Sepia. Grainy black and white. Rising hues of blue sky, gold sand, grey rock, white water around the hooves of the two men’s horses as the past dips and rises over petrified dunes into a cinema present of movement and relationship between the three of us, that is, between Butch, Sundance, and me, Etta. “Can I move? I’m better when I move,” Sundance says, and of course he means he’s good with his gun when he can spin it from its holster, can turn on his feet to shoot in all directions; then, he’s a man in lethal motion, he’s a better man. His love of movement made the real Sundance Kid a natural for cinematic resurrection. He was meant to escape through a screen from the stasis of history. He was glorious, or Robert Redford was, running as The Kid embodied atop the boxcars of the speeding Union Pacific Flyer, or hurtling toward the cliff’s edge to leap, cursing, into the rushing river, or scrambling, drenched in sweat, over escarpments and boulders. And yet I found him most beautiful in stillness. Just his hand raised in deception to his cocked hat, or his jaw clenched, or his sudden glance of menace, shot quick above a deck of cards.

10
Maybe he seemed most alive to me in those black and white photographs that document our happiest time in Manhattan, after we’d left Wyoming for Bolivia and waited for our ship to leave harbor. The photographs—all real historical artifacts that Bill Goldman embedded mid-point in our film in a sudden flash of light—of New York’s Fifth Avenue, of Central Park’s wide lake and fountain, the West Side’s intricate architectures, remind me how photographs can eclipse the moving image as memory. Photographs insist that although movement loves the future, stillness captures the perpetual past, the three of us still alive together in elegant Manhattan society. We rode in carriages, gambled, danced, took carnival rides, visited Coney Island, posed with our arms around one another. I love those detailed photos that an eight-year-old kid of the 1960s might study, hoping to glimpse her own mother in them as she once was, a dark-haired and slender girl at the end of her twenties, her arms also around two men together: a man who loved music, and a man who loved words—her husband and her friend. Hers is another time, far beyond my own turn of the century. But I hover as Etta beside this girl who knows me and my men as her family. With her, I sort invisibly through her photographs of her mother with the two handsome guys. I admire images of their three bodies spread together in relaxed configuration across a large sleepy sheepdog, and of their grins as they raise glasses of champagne at a party, and of their rumpled heads close together where they lie beneath a blanket, not long after the three of them arrived in the city, just as we did. Three young creative hopefuls from a mid-west college town, two men out of the army, a bookish woman, and all of them in awe of New York City. I wish the three of us had stayed in New York too, and to hell with Bolivia. When I see the girl’s photos, I’m surprised to find among them several of myself and of Butch and Sundance looking as we did in our movie—as Ross, Newman, Redford—and that the city has changed so little in five decades. I’ve seen the future clearly. Bill understood my life was filled with scenes I could and couldn’t bear, so he’d make my future easy for me in his script. He said that I could leave, if I really loved them both. We agreed I’d tell Butch and Sundance, “I’ll sew your socks and stitch you when you’re wounded, and anything you’ll ask of me I’ll do, except one thing; I won’t watch you die. I’ll miss that scene if you don’t mind.” Characters do have choices, for a while. But love demands a disappearance. Sooner or later, someone will vanish, along with all their memories—disease, and guilt, and death, those can’t be stopped—and that’s a fact that can’t ever be explained, except in fiction and in movies, and even then, it’s pretty hard to believe.

ETTA GOES

Any story, even this one, can only have one ending. Not that it matters. But this is what I learned, loving these two men—outlaws, actors, illusions, Butch and The Sundance Kid—who were headed for bloody deaths. I could write my own ending but not theirs; they could only be themselves. At least Bill gave me one shot to have his script go my way, over hot coffees, in the solemn aftermath of multiple murders. That brief coffee scene has a golden shade, it’s a kind of cinema balm after all those grey shots of corpses, the Bolivian bandits Sundance and Butch have slaughtered in their failure to go straight. Only the screenwriter knew just how much I still dreamed of a farm at dusk, of the two men I loved walking home to me tired and yearning—or, of a ranch, with animals we could all care for together as outlaws happily retired, invisible, kind, and settled. But Butch and Sundance answer my suggestions, “I don’t know how to farm,” and “It’s hard, the hours are brutal,” and “you have to be a kid to own a ranch.” Sullen. Fated. In the original script, I had more lines. I apologized for hoping. Better that I just look instead straight into the camera. My face fills the screen. Remember this: my wide-eyed desolation that they will die. My close-up, before I vanish from the story. Katharine Ross, as me, wished for more scenes to act as Etta when some of her lines were cut from the final film. But the real Etta vanished from history just as abruptly. No one knows what became of Etta Place, though folklorists and historians speculate she lived to an old age, undetected in some tiny house in the American West. In the movie, I choose my future. I have power. In deep night, the fire is dying and none of us can sleep. I lie with my back to Sundance—whom I have so often faced in the tangle of our sheets, my head against his shoulder—and now I speak only to you, small screen-smitten child of the future, your heart speeding in the dark of the movie theater, your pre-adolescent blood sick with premonition of the awful goodbyes that one day you will make. “I might go back ahead of you,” I say, directly to that girl, finding her across the decades between us. She sits up straight beside her mother in the theater’s velvet seat. Her mother stares up at the screen, sensing suddenly that she too will go ahead of her two men. Like me, she’ll miss the scene of their dying. I can see their unknown story’s end as clearly as my own: the hundreds who will gather in mourning, first in a gallery for the girl’s mother in 1994; then, at a concert for her father in 2016; and lastly, at the Ziegfeld movie theater for Bill, in 2019. Each New York City space will fill with the people who loved these three and learned from them, and with all those still living whom they loved. Loss gathers an enormous crowd. Songs and scenes play on nostalgia’s screen, in homage. So Butch and Sundance don’t stop me from going home—they can’t. My end comes early and quietly. I won’t have to see them both go too; that’s for some other audience. Sundance says, “Whatever you want, Etta,” and Butch says, “Whatever she wants,” and he lowers his head beneath a blanket.

FADE OUT

This scene in which Butch, Sundance, and Etta lie apart on the cold ground that holds us may not be remembered by many as an essential one. But the girl of the future and I stare at one another through the movie screen as she writes these words. It’s just her and me now. She’s much older than me, older even than her own dead mother, and surrounded by photos and film stills and novels that stir up the past. She tells me, I believe that movies are made of memory and desire. You live inside the characters and scenes, you live your story beneath the story, you meet your hidden self in anonymous darkness, you see your family and the ones who shaped you, you enter their minds, you hear their voices, you try to let them go—always and never—those ones you watched grow older and transform into breathtaking versions of themselves as they learned who they were, and what they could bear along the way. A movie is only your movie, and no one else’s. On our last night together, filmed in the low firelight and shadow of facts and stories, Sundance, Butch, and I (and this writer, her mother, her father, and Bill) agree that I will go ahead, without them. The order of our dying makes no difference. We don’t talk any more about it. Inside the past, everyone that matters still moves in endless film reel and never dies. So, I figure we’ll find each other again later—in photographs, in music, in books and screenplays that line the shelves, in old theaters like the Sutton, the Ziegfeld, the Plaza, the Alcyon, and in someone’s memories. Just picture the three of us together as we never were and will always be in my imagination: in this unforgettable movie, where most of what follows, especially love, is true.