I first saw the original 1956 version of Invasion of the Body-Snatchers in the late fifties, when I was six. It seemed to me terrifying and not at all dismissible. Of course I wasn’t alert to the politics informing the film. What impressed me was the apparent willingness of ordinary people to be led, transformed by an extra-terrestrial conspiracy. Though I don’t think I laughed at any point when I first saw the film, and felt that it was not a standard made-for-children television movie, I found it not at all surprising, many years later, that in a review of the 1978 remake of the film, Pauline Kael of The New Yorker began by declaring it “more sheer fun than any movie” she’d seen in a long time. The fun was more than a matter of good lines and worked-up spooky nuances. It had more to do, Kael wrote, with the “deliciously paranoid theme: trying to hang on to your human individuality while those around you are contentedly turning into vegetables and insisting that you join them.” Kael notes that the original Body-Snatchers had “most of the humor…excised,” though even in that Don Siegel version an adult viewer might surely have found reason to laugh at the clueless inanities uttered by several characters.
Of course it is impossible today for an adult viewer to look at either version of the film without thinking it a warning of things to come, focused not principally upon a demonic leader reducing his followers to swine or to wild-eyed, empty-headed MAGA enthusiasts, but upon ordinary, compliant persons, initially resistant in some cases to what is demanded of them, but in the end too weak to resist, their capitulation the stuff of horror or of comedy. Kael notes that in the 1978 Phil Kaufman version, set in a San Francisco notably hospitable to eccentrics and enthusiasts of the Human Potential movement, “it is not surprising to hear the reborn flower people proselytizing for their soulless condition as a higher form of life. ‘Don’t be trapped by old concepts,’ one of them says.”
My own childish, terrified take on Body-Snatchers was surely colored, determined by an episode in my family past.
Who are you, little girl? I am Peggy.
Words scripted for my six-year-old brother for a scene written and directed by my fifteen- year-old sister.
The plot was simple: I, the unwitting victim, the mark, would enter her own bedroom, expecting to play with her dolls, only to find brother Jimmy propped on her bed, stuffed into her favorite party dress, a pink bow stuck to his buzz-cut boy-head. On the sidelines, my sister and other brother would play the chorus, chanting and echoing Jimmy’s lines, asserting that he, not I, was Peggy. Predictably provoked to tears, I would tear out of the room to find my mother, who, as in a horror movie, would receive me with the scripted refrain, who are you, little girl, who are you?
And so, precisely according to plan, the scene unfolded, complete with cry-baby Peggy reliably running to her mommy for solace and being refused, eliciting peals of laughter from her sister and brothers. I was four.
It was 1956, the year the original The Invasion of the Body Snatchers hit the theaters in the U.S, though not in Venezuela where I was living at the time in an oil camp where my father worked for Mere Grande, a subsidiary of Gulf Oil. My family lived in an American pre-fab house surrounded by a vast, verdant lawn populated with bougainvillea, flowering guava, tamarind, coconut and one enormous ceiba. In our back yard were banana, pineapple and fruit-laden papaya.
As I told the “who are you, little girl” story recently to a group of dinner guests, it occurred to me (with the shocked support of my in- terlocutors) that this episode might qualify as a case of childhood trauma, though I recovered more or less easily from the episode. In my generally charmed life, where traumas are hard to come by, I was glad to elicit laughs and also some sympathy for the childish cruelties visited upon me. I had been a resilient little girl and quickly got over the jokes frequently played upon me, though surely I had been marked in some way, damaged. So I began to suspect.
By the time I first saw the original Body Snatchers in 1960, I was duly terrified by the film’s nightmarish vision of widespread domination by a foreign or alien power. This I remember. I remember what I felt when the character played by Kevin McCarthy flees from a locked ward crying “I’m not crazy,” only to have to face the skeptical townspeople reluctant to believe that “something evil” has “taken possession of this town.” I was persuaded that ordinary people were telling the truth when they noted that their own family members were in fact “imposters.”
In fact, I lived in a house—several houses over a number of years– of terrified adults for whom the threat of Communist conspiracies and subversions was real. My family had just fled Fidel Castro’s revolutionary regime in Cuba, and the Communist menace was a persistent theme flogged by every adult I met, virtually all of them rabidly right-wing Americans obsessed with our vulnerability to “them.” Had I been a little older, and more sophisticated, I’d have seen in these adults—my own parents, aunts and uncles, family friends—the signs of mass hysteria cited in the film by the perfectly sane, impeccably dressed Dr. Miles Bennett, who first accepts the idea that patients’ reports of intimates who are “not themselves” are simply delusional.
Soon, however, Bennett must revise his medically “sound” opinion as he is called to his friend Jack’s place to view one of the “pod people” alarmingly in the making, laid out like a corpse on Jack’s pool table—proof that more than ‘mass-hysteria’ is at issue.
Even now, I wonder why such a film should have affected me as it did. For one thing, it was winter; I had never been so cold or seen snow before. I had never before lived in a house with a basement or gone to a school run by nuns. I had never worn a uniform daily. I was the proverbial stranger in a strange land. And I had never, until then, been exposed to the power of television.
A year earlier, after the coup of Marcos Perez Jimenez, we had left Venezuela for Cuba, where Fidel Castro had “liberated” the country from Batista’s dictatorial rule and everyone was full of hope. My parents even built a small house in Varadero where I went to school briefly with the local guajiros. But soon Fidel openly declared himself a Communist and we, along with many others, abandoned the beach house and bank account to travel to Miami, eventually finding our way north where my father had fled earlier and was efficiently going bankrupt after investing his savings in a company run by thieves.
In the States everyone spoke English, but however thrilling it was to converse easily with everyone in the language spoken in my home, I was told not to speak to strangers. The Boston Strangler was on the loose; the story of the Lindbergh kidnapping was still fresh in my family’s imag- ination. The United States was not a safe place, nothing like the walled-in oil camp I had known in Puerto La Cruz. Nothing like Varadero where I had walked to school up the street alone, then gone swimming in the ocean after school.
Fear of Communism dominated the family’s right-wing politics, and at seven I was already highly predisposed to the dread of dictatorial regimes. It was the time of the Red Scare. At school there were air-raid drills. Our better-off neighbors were building bomb shelters. All this was in the air when I sat down in our basement to watch Invasion of the Body Snatchers one winter afternoon.
Probably I was sick that day, allowed to watch TV while my mother shopped and cooked and did laundry for the family. The days were dreary and short: my father would leave the house at dawn to work for his dying company in New York City and in the evening dark come home. Outdoors, snow turned to slush, and the scene as I remember it was decidedly unlovely. We were a long way from the tropical paradise of my birth.
Much on my mind, Body-Snatchers offered what seemed to me a vivid picture of what could happen were Fidel to take over the world. This much I thought I ‘understood.’ We would all turn into robotic operatives of the State. At night I prayed that Fidel would die. My cousins in Cuba, I was told, were already ‘brainwashed’, zealously cutting sugar cane for the Revolution, spending months away from their parents during harvest time. How soon might this happen to me, here, in my new country? The irony that I was myself totally in thrall to my parents’ ideological perspec- tive was of course nothing that could occur to me then. The warnings and threats routinely issued by Senator Joseph McCarthy had been regarded with approval by my credulous parents. The Communist body snatchers were, apparently, everywhere.
In New Jersey my glamorous Cuban mother, no longer the queen of her household with a retinue of servants, had turned into an American hag, wearing pastel-colored pedal pushers, and instead of jewelry, enormous pink foam curlers. Elsewhere a fabulous cook, in New Jersey she fell into feeding the five of us TV dinners. She would drive us in the morning to our grim parochial school in a beige Chevrolet station wagon and pick us up in the afternoon. Her former life of entertaining elegantly in flowing sequined cocktail dresses and patent leather spike heels was no more. We had all been spoiled by our years of pampered colonialist life; in retrospect I am embarrassed by my tragic sense of loss at the time, a sense I registered even at seven. Nevertheless, the gray sadness that colored that blessedly short period of my family’s life was real.
During this tumultuous period of family history I became very pious. I had learned about St. Theresa—god walks among the pots and pans—and, yearning to be like her, looked for god’s presence everywhere. I wished in vain for visions, but the idea of being possessed, of becoming one with the body and blood of Christ was less than attractive, not to mention incomprehensible. On the other hand, to be spiritually possessed by God, to be moved to the point of surrender, to be snatched, as it were, was, so I was told in Catholic school, divinely to be wished—so that nightly and fervently I prayed, a devout little wannabe saint.
Yet as I watched Invasion of the Body Snatchers, alone in our crummy basement, nothing about saintly surrender or the threat of Communist world-domination contaminated the pure thrill and terror of the experience. There was something primal in the fear that overtook me. Maybe the long-suppressed memory of my brother dressed in MY clothes, sitting on MY bed—my trusted brother, beribboned, an impostor usurping my identity at age four—did have something to do with my susceptibility to the idea that even “normal people” may be moved, or driven, to lose themselves and to do terrible things. How not to recoil from the sight of real bubbling pods brewing seeds which would become the very real doubles of those in the household? The sight of those hidden husks in Miles’ greenhouse bursting with malignant intention struck something deep in me.
Does this film about the fear of being overtaken by an alien force still haunt me? Not exactly. If not, then why did it immediately come to mind when the opportunity arose to write about a film that had had some importance for me?
We live in a time when many voting-age citizens have become willing supporters and instruments of a grotesque malefactor whose outra- geous misdeeds provide daily headlines. Often, I think of them as having been snatched—remarkable really— in their blind and thoughtless rage to follow their leader wherever he may take them. When viewing the film’s Santa Mira residents processing, zombie-like, through the city streets, it’s hard not to associate their malady with something akin to the mindless MAGA-hysteria possessing the American multitudes. As I observe our liberal democracy going not so gradually to hell, many of my neighbors having fallen prey to the seductions of an American Fascism, I’m not so very surprised that Body Snatchers seems improbably compelling again, more than sixty years after I first allowed it to affect me.
In the years that followed my first viewing of Invasion of the Body Snatchers I traveled to several countries which exploded politically while we were in residence and from which my family had to evacuate. Everywhere, it seemed, there were wars and revolutions and failed or failing liberation movements. After Venezuela and Cuba, we moved from Indonesia to Nigeria to Libya and back again to Nigeria—vastly different countries with vastly different histories whose citizens underwent terrible strife. Though in each case my family managed to escape, the record of blasted hopes and lives snatched from what had been promising beginnings was impossible to miss. Neither was it possible to miss the role of the oil companies my father worked for in prompting or promoting the dislocations and terrors unleashed again and again in those years.
My formal education had been necessarily erratic as we evacuated and moved from place to place. Sometimes there were schools; other times not. I had witnessed killings in the street, terrible poverty, the violent overthrow of leaders and the insistent flow of propaganda disseminated by persons with no feeling at all for the lives of ordinary people, most of them living in unspeakable conditions. Though I was accustomed to crises and sudden evacuations from what had been our home in one oil camp or another, I had never experienced political oppression in the way it was felt by citizens in countries in turmoil.
By the time I was sent away to high school in Rome in the late 1960s, at the time of the Aldo Moro kidnapping and the so-called “leaden years,” I was equipped, as never before, to think about body-snatchers in ways far removed from the paranoid fantasies promoted by my family. There were, to be sure, real dangers posed by political fanatics and tyrants who targeted not only their political opponents but citizens and civilians with little or no investment in politics. As a teenager mainly on her own in a city like Rome it was hard to dwell overmuch on the activities of the Baader-Meinhoff gang or to ignore the siren call of high fashion and cappuccinos on the Via Veneto. Only when I went to a small liberals arts college in Saratoga Springs, and thereby initiated a total break from my family, did I fully come to terms with what was entailed—for better or for worse—in being snatched. Snatched by an alternative vision of life, and snatched too by a freshman English teacher to whom I’ve now been married for more than fifty years. Complicated, our story, but fit for another telling, elsewhere, and yet here, by way of conclusion, a way into another dimension of snatching.
Body-snatchers—actual, figurative, imagined, feared, solicited, seductive, loathsome. Often far more interested in minds than in bodies. Really it’s not always easy to separate the one variant from the other. Daphne Merkin notes, in an essay, that “on the first Friday after Sigmund Freud’s death, having accepted more than a half century’s imposed impiety at her husband’s insistence,” Martha Bernays “started to light the Sabbath candles again.” With that, Merkin contends, “she was being more than assertive. She was being defiant…. re-establishing her autonomy by renouncing a pattern of submission to her husband’s wishes. She was taking a step backward, toward her family ethos, before she became the compliant, devoted caretaker that Freud desired her to be…” The Freud marriage was famously harmonious, “but the couple’s divergent attitudes toward Judaism remained a source of underground conflict,” and Freud “delighted in ribbing Martha about her religious attachment,” even “demanded that Martha not fast on Yom Kippur, arguing that she was too thin to fast.”
The Freud marriage will perhaps not seem a promising way to bring this little essay to completion, and in truth my own take on Freud, and his marriage, is considerably more generous than Merkin’s. But yes, it’s true that persons who allow themselves to be imposed upon, who are inveterately compliant, are more apt to be coerced, controlled, snatched away from what might otherwise have been their desires, even from their pious natures. There was, for Martha Bernays, a will—or willingness—to submit for the sake of advantages, for the sake in fact of a harmonious marriage to the man she adored. That hers was a case of willing submission all too familiar among women of Martha’s generation, including highly educated and privileged women, is part of Merkin’s argument, and it is of course indisputable. And yet, it is hard to think of a woman like Martha, a mother to several brilliant children, including Anna Freud, as in any way unfortunate, snatched from triumph or ambition. But she was indeed “snatched” from what might have been another trajectory, and it is not at all preposterous to think of the Freud marriage as weirdly emblematic, however exalted the principal players.
But let’s return again, briefly, to Pauline Kael, who spoke of the “deliciously paranoid theme” of the Body-Snatchers films—using the word “paranoid” as if it might signify the fear of persons confronted by an actual, indisputably real threat to life and limb. What presumably makes the paranoid theme, so-called, delicious? Obviously, it lends itself to the species of anxiety and terror generated by successful thrillers, films which are more than popular entertainment while yet trading in the special effects that move us to wonder and unease. Kael rightly notes the “supernatural and fantastic visual style” of the Kaufman remake, but the paranoid theme is surely an indispensable component of both versions. What’s delicious about the paranoia we experience—the fear that every least eruption in the film is a token of impending disaster— is that it is made to seem just barely plausible while also seeming patently over the top. Is there “paranoia” in contemplating the all-too-familiar readiness even of extraordinary persons to comply with the demands placed upon them by husbands, wives, lovers, bosses, program administrators? Kael speaks of the “undiluted pleasure and excitement” we experience as viewers of the Kaufman film, and I suppose I felt that too when I first saw the Siegel film when I was a kid. In both cases the “delicious” paranoia must surely be an effect of feeling that the stakes are high, that there is something more than the momentary thrill in submitting to the terror, and that the threat to “human individuality” is an idea comprehensive enough to enlist our sympathies.
The story Merkin and others have told about the Freud marriage is compelling in part because both characters have some claim on our interest and sympathy. But it does, in its way, also lend itself to the paranoid theme, in that Martha’s compliance can seem to symbolize the fate of women in general and, by extension, the price most of us are surely willing to pay to appease those who—in one degree or another—have the power to move us to compliance, especially when we have been made to feel that we submit for our own good or for the good of others in our care. The “deliciously paranoid theme” is—must be—felt to be delicious because, outside the theatrical/ cinematic extravagances unleashed in the Body-Snatchers films themselves, we understand that we are always endangered, that we are required to be alert to the forces that would turn us into wholly compliant beings, and that we have it in us to resist. Even Freud’s Martha found ways to resist—ways large and small, and not always desperate. Submission is terrifyingly inscribed in the Body-Snatchers films, but so also is what might be called Againstness.